Topic: The Union Way Up
AndrewAV's photo
Tue 01/27/09 09:47 PM





Many hundreds of thousands if not millions made a good liveing for many many years and sent their kids to collage to better themselves. I make 21.85 an hour pay forty five in union dues and forty five for family medical, a company pension also is included its a nice one. My union has done alot for me and my family. Good luck sending your kids to collage I am wondering how I will do it on what I make. Did I mension my family medical is only a ten buck co pay? and 100% after that. Its the only thing keeping me from moveing to canada. :wink:


That's how my friends know the union. People in my area try to get in the union.

Why do the same job and not be in the union? Electricians, painters, plumbers, nurses, teachers, grocery store, and more.

I have a friend that is a non-union heavy equipment operator. He is trying to get into the union's school for that field so he can do the same job in the union. It's difficult to find good paying non-union jobs in that field.


then the problem is the union. Unions force their influence on the industry by disallowing jobs to be given to those that are not members of the union.


I didn't say that anyone was disallowed jobs. I said it was difficult to find "good paying" jobs in that field not difficult to find jobs in that field.

I know union and non-union painters, brick layers and a heavy equipment operator. They make a lot less money and don't have the benefit package that the union people in the same field have.

I


But the reason they're not 'good paying" is because that is what the market has determined the value of that job to be. If it requires little skill (I have several friends that used to do construction and none have described any of the equipment as difficult) then more people can do it. A higher supply of able workers means it will offer less money. By unionizing the industry and artificially inflating the value of those jobs, all you do is increase the final cost of the product.

Unions are beneficial only to those that are in them. Everyone else gets hosed.

Winx's photo
Tue 01/27/09 10:00 PM






Many hundreds of thousands if not millions made a good liveing for many many years and sent their kids to collage to better themselves. I make 21.85 an hour pay forty five in union dues and forty five for family medical, a company pension also is included its a nice one. My union has done alot for me and my family. Good luck sending your kids to collage I am wondering how I will do it on what I make. Did I mension my family medical is only a ten buck co pay? and 100% after that. Its the only thing keeping me from moveing to canada. :wink:


That's how my friends know the union. People in my area try to get in the union.

Why do the same job and not be in the union? Electricians, painters, plumbers, nurses, teachers, grocery store, and more.

I have a friend that is a non-union heavy equipment operator. He is trying to get into the union's school for that field so he can do the same job in the union. It's difficult to find good paying non-union jobs in that field.


then the problem is the union. Unions force their influence on the industry by disallowing jobs to be given to those that are not members of the union.


I didn't say that anyone was disallowed jobs. I said it was difficult to find "good paying" jobs in that field not difficult to find jobs in that field.

I know union and non-union painters, brick layers and a heavy equipment operator. They make a lot less money and don't have the benefit package that the union people in the same field have.



But the reason they're not 'good paying" is because that is what the market has determined the value of that job to be. If it requires little skill (I have several friends that used to do construction and none have described any of the equipment as difficult) then more people can do it. A higher supply of able workers means it will offer less money. By unionizing the industry and artificially inflating the value of those jobs, all you do is increase the final cost of the product.

Unions are beneficial only to those that are in them. Everyone else gets hosed.


Heavy equipment operator is skilled. Teachers and nurses are skilled. There are also the firefighters and the police officers and more.

nogames39's photo
Tue 01/27/09 11:50 PM
Look. TV makers are skilled. Does it honestly make you want to pay the price higher than the market determines?

nogames39's photo
Tue 01/27/09 11:50 PM
Edited by nogames39 on Tue 01/27/09 11:51 PM
Double post. Wired, this site does it. If you click on "post" exactly when the page refreshes, - you're doubled!

Winx's photo
Tue 01/27/09 11:55 PM

Double post. Wired, this site does it. If you click on "post" exactly when the page refreshes, - you're doubled!


You refresh the page at the same time that you post?

Winx's photo
Tue 01/27/09 11:59 PM

Look. TV makers are skilled. Does it honestly make you want to pay the price higher than the market determines?


I want the friend that I know that is a heavy equipment operator to make maybe $20/hr. with benefits to use a crane instead of the $12/hr. he makes now with no benefits.

madisonman's photo
Wed 01/28/09 01:37 AM




and what does your job entail, exactly?


I am guessing it entails something with a high barrier to entry. Judging by the spelling.


lol. I'm just curious because he makes slightly more than me and pays $300 less a month than I would for medical and I get no pension. All the while, my job requires extensive knowledge to keep up on everything and expensive ($40k and counting) tools to do that job. not to mention that southern california is not not known for it's cheap cost of living.
slightly more? it is 400 a month more and my cost of liveing in Ohio is far cheaper than yours. Somehow my company does verry well with its highly paid highly motivated work force. Gee I wish I didnt have to work in the union I could make less money and pay more for insurance. I just waste that 400 anyhow on clothes, tires on my daughters car, braces for the kids. Vet bills for the family pet, dumb stuff like that

Winx's photo
Wed 01/28/09 09:18 AM





and what does your job entail, exactly?


I am guessing it entails something with a high barrier to entry. Judging by the spelling.


lol. I'm just curious because he makes slightly more than me and pays $300 less a month than I would for medical and I get no pension. All the while, my job requires extensive knowledge to keep up on everything and expensive ($40k and counting) tools to do that job. not to mention that southern california is not not known for it's cheap cost of living.
slightly more? it is 400 a month more and my cost of liveing in Ohio is far cheaper than yours. Somehow my company does verry well with its highly paid highly motivated work force. Gee I wish I didnt have to work in the union I could make less money and pay more for insurance. I just waste that 400 anyhow on clothes, tires on my daughters car, braces for the kids. Vet bills for the family pet, dumb stuff like that


The pension is not too shabby either.

catwoman96's photo
Wed 01/28/09 09:27 AM
i used to be a union employee...teamsters...
drove one of them durn forktrucks and was number one in senority when i quit.


that being said I cant imagine nursing ever being a union controlled profession. I think it would be chaotic

Winx's photo
Wed 01/28/09 09:29 AM

i used to be a union employee...teamsters...
drove one of them durn forktrucks and was number one in senority when i quit.


that being said I cant imagine nursing ever being a union controlled profession. I think it would be chaotic



http://www.uannurse.org/

catwoman96's photo
Wed 01/28/09 09:35 AM


i used to be a union employee...teamsters...
drove one of them durn forktrucks and was number one in senority when i quit.


that being said I cant imagine nursing ever being a union controlled profession. I think it would be chaotic



http://www.uannurse.org/


i dont want to be union. I negotiated my own pay using my years and level of experiance, and flexability in scheduling.

I found being a part of a union a buncha crock....the place i worked at took none of those tihngs into consideration. it was entirely based on senority.

benefits rocked...and that was the only thing I liked. benefits (not pay per hour)is what is causing the auto industry to suffer right now. PLUS demand for new vehicles has decreased (affordability perhaps??)

speaking of the auto industry mostly right now..........or else the increase of costs for new cars will keep going up till its utterly ridiculous.

no photo
Wed 01/28/09 10:24 AM





Can't you see that this is all talk? This has been going on forever the last 20 years...NAFTA...GATT... all the uneven trade agreements. the sell out of corporations, AMERICAN ones...for the cheap labor etc etc. the influx of illegals hurt the working class & continues to.

Rockefeller Reps ...Limosine Libs... don't you see they are all the same?

What I don't understand is why everyone bashes the religious right when they have moral integrity & a conscience to do what's right?
I never bother any religiouse person in their church of choice on Sunday morning. I expect them not to bug me on election day or at the school board meetings or townhalls.


They have every right to have a say in what goes on in govt whether you like it or not. Why am I not surprized that you missed the point?
I suppose I have to explain the seperation of Church and State. WIsh I had more time.


Here's what the bill of rights says...

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.

This means govt. does not have the right to interfere with religious freedom or expression of. There is nothing there that says people of faith can't have a say in their govt. That's a lie to say otherwise.





What part of "make no law respecting an establishment of religion" do you not understand? You can believe whatever nonsensical poppycock you want. But you can't legislate those beliefs. Because you believe an imaginary skydaddy says it's a no no is not a basis for any law. Given the history of Christianity and the hate, death and destruction it has always brought it's vitally important that we not allow it to infect our government.

beeorganic's photo
Wed 01/28/09 11:11 AM
Those who can succeed in life on their own merits,do... those who can't, join unions. It is my belief that REAL men don't need to hide behind the apron strings of a "mommy" figure (union leadership) to take care them (job protection). "Mommy" negotiates your allowance (pay and benefits) but charges a monthly fee to do so. "Mommy" tells you what to do in regards to your responsibilities at work and when to throw a temper tantrum in public for attention (strike or picket). "Mommy" protects you when screw up (intentionally or unintentionally). If you don't do what "mommy" says, she punishes you. If you have to make a decision at work and not sure what to do, you have to ask "mommy". If your feelings are hurt when you see a REAL man not part of the family doing your job and making you look like a wimp, you go running and crying to "mommy". One doesn't need to be a licensed psychologist to see union "males" have some form of an "Edopus complex" (with "mommy") coupled with abandonment issues and are afraid to move out of "mommy's" basement. I speculate union boys/adolescents are naturally submissive and have made a consensual and cognitive decision to be controlled/dominated by "mommy". "Mommy" will give you everything you need to survive in life, except your employment manhood. Those who can do, those who won't/can't, become union eunuchs.

For you female union types, just exchange "mommy" for "daddy" with an "Electra Complex".

madisonman's photo
Wed 01/28/09 01:09 PM



i used to be a union employee...teamsters...
drove one of them durn forktrucks and was number one in senority when i quit.


that being said I cant imagine nursing ever being a union controlled profession. I think it would be chaotic



http://www.uannurse.org/


i dont want to be union. I negotiated my own pay using my years and level of experiance, and flexability in scheduling.

I found being a part of a union a buncha crock....the place i worked at took none of those tihngs into consideration. it was entirely based on senority.

benefits rocked...and that was the only thing I liked. benefits (not pay per hour)is what is causing the auto industry to suffer right now. PLUS demand for new vehicles has decreased (affordability perhaps??)

speaking of the auto industry mostly right now..........or else the increase of costs for new cars will keep going up till its utterly ridiculous.
Come talk to me when your getting old and they need to downsize and get ride of people with accured vacation time and they have some fresh hot young nurse waiting to take your place........

catwoman96's photo
Wed 01/28/09 01:23 PM




i used to be a union employee...teamsters...
drove one of them durn forktrucks and was number one in senority when i quit.


that being said I cant imagine nursing ever being a union controlled profession. I think it would be chaotic



http://www.uannurse.org/


i dont want to be union. I negotiated my own pay using my years and level of experiance, and flexability in scheduling.


I found being a part of a union a buncha crock....the place i worked at took none of those tihngs into consideration. it was entirely based on senority.

benefits rocked...and that was the only thing I liked. benefits (not pay per hour)is what is causing the auto industry to suffer right now. PLUS demand for new vehicles has decreased (affordability perhaps??)

speaking of the auto industry mostly right now..........or else the increase of costs for new cars will keep going up till its utterly ridiculous.
Come talk to me when your getting old and they need to downsize and get ride of people with accured vacation time and they have some fresh hot young nurse waiting to take your place........


i work with plenty of nurse who have 20 to 30 years in the organization I currently work with.

with age comes experiance. I am not hired becasue of how i look.

and again....you do know my benefits arent nothing to brag about......and at my current postion i do not receive any vacation time. because of the job position i took.

i WOULD hate to have some nurse who had been there a month longer than me...come BID on my job...and force me to choose another job and actually take a staff position for a unit.


madisonman's photo
Wed 01/28/09 01:34 PM
Well I have dated many nurses and I know the stories well. The Largest hospital in cleveland is Union some of the smaller ones are non union. most of the non union nurses I know wish they were union. I know of one Dr who saw Obama bumper stickers on his nurses cars and he told them if Obama is elected he would let two of them go. I hope you never face something like that but if your not union you would have to listen to it.

catwoman96's photo
Wed 01/28/09 04:25 PM
i am quite happy with my current type of employment.

again without a union.


Winx's photo
Wed 01/28/09 04:28 PM

i am quite happy with my current type of employment.

again without a union.




Cat,

You don't have vacation time? I thought that was unusual for most jobs.

catwoman96's photo
Wed 01/28/09 04:31 PM


i am quite happy with my current type of employment.

again without a union.




Cat,

You don't have vacation time? I thought that was unusual for most jobs.


i am resource staff...i am required to work 24 hours per week.

my rate of pay is very high compared to if I took a regular staff position on one of the floors between the two hospitals I work for.

I am unbenefited...and I dont accumulate paid time off....although I pick the two days I work every week...and I think that I can request some unpaid time of if I wanted to.

that being said my hourly rate is quite a bit higher than if I took a staff postion. and I could chose to take a benefited position now...but I dont want to pay the benefits.

does that make any sense??

Winx's photo
Wed 01/28/09 04:34 PM



i am quite happy with my current type of employment.

again without a union.




Cat,

You don't have vacation time? I thought that was unusual for most jobs.


i am resource staff...i am required to work 24 hours per week.

my rate of pay is very high compared to if I took a regular staff position on one of the floors between the two hospitals I work for.

I am unbenefited...and I dont accumulate paid time off....although I pick the two days I work every week...and I think that I can request some unpaid time of if I wanted to.

that being said my hourly rate is quite a bit higher than if I took a staff postion. and I could chose to take a benefited position now...but I dont want to pay the benefits.

does that make any sense??



Yes, it makes sense. You're part-time. Part-time doesn't get benefits or vacation or sick time. Yes, I can see that you could make more money per hour in your field.

I would find it difficult to work 12 hours straight.