Previous 1
Topic: Arizona Republicans vs. Atheism
TexasScoundrel's photo
Sat 01/26/13 11:42 PM
If a person wants to believe something, fine. But, forcing others to believe it is un-American. If you live in Arizona, let your leaders know what you think.

Arizona Republicans Propose Bill That Would Not Allow Atheists To Graduate High School

http://www.patheos.com/blogs/friendlyatheist/2013/01/25/arizona-republicans-propose-bill-that-would-not-allow-atheists-to-graduate-high-school/

jessejames2's photo
Sat 01/26/13 11:51 PM
Yeah I'm not clicking that link. Instead, I'll just guess it's the baby boomers doing their best to screw with everything as usual.

metalwing's photo
Sun 01/27/13 01:04 AM
The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.

Conrad_73's photo
Sun 01/27/13 01:25 AM

Yeah I'm not clicking that link. Instead, I'll just guess it's the baby boomers doing their best to screw with everything as usual.
what's that got to do with Baby-Boomers?
Do you actually understand the Term?
Hope you Guys will do a better Job when you have to man up!bigsmile

Conrad_73's photo
Sun 01/27/13 01:28 AM

The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile

metalwing's photo
Sun 01/27/13 01:34 AM


The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile


Perhaps. But if any of those high school students went to court, would they be required to put their hand on a bible and swear to tell the truth "so help me God"?

Conrad_73's photo
Sun 01/27/13 01:40 AM



The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile


Perhaps. But if any of those high school students went to court, would they be required to put their hand on a bible and swear to tell the truth "so help me God"?
they could just Affirm,I think!

Affirmation in law, a declaration made by and allowed to those who conscientiously object to taking an oath (WIKI)

Conrad_73's photo
Sun 01/27/13 01:57 AM



The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile


Perhaps. But if any of those high school students went to court, would they be required to put their hand on a bible and swear to tell the truth "so help me God"?


The Constitution states that no Religious Test is required to hold Public Office!
Would be kind of absurd to demand a Religious test for Citizenship by those of whom no Religious Test is required!laugh

metalwing's photo
Sun 01/27/13 02:03 AM




The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile


Perhaps. But if any of those high school students went to court, would they be required to put their hand on a bible and swear to tell the truth "so help me God"?


The Constitution states that no Religious Test is required to hold Public Office!
Would be kind of absurd to demand a Religious test for Citizenship by those of whom no Religious Test is required!laugh


Graduation from High School isn't a public office or a test for citizenship. I suppose the goal is to introduce some patriotism into public schools but with today's climate, I am not sure the lawmakers aren't just shooting themselves in the foot with this one.:smile:

Conrad_73's photo
Sun 01/27/13 04:23 AM





The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile


Perhaps. But if any of those high school students went to court, would they be required to put their hand on a bible and swear to tell the truth "so help me God"?


The Constitution states that no Religious Test is required to hold Public Office!
Would be kind of absurd to demand a Religious test for Citizenship by those of whom no Religious Test is required!laugh


Graduation from High School isn't a public office or a test for citizenship. I suppose the goal is to introduce some patriotism into public schools but with today's climate, I am not sure the lawmakers aren't just shooting themselves in the foot with this one.:smile:
I still think it would amount to dgree of Citizenship Test,since if you don't take the Oath,you can't graduate,and actually,no matter how hard you studied,and how good your Grades,you'd be automatically relegated to a Second-Class Citizen,with less advantages than those who just barely make the Grades,but take that proposed Oath!
Sure will help to raise the level of Competence in the State and Nation!:laughing:

msharmony's photo
Sun 01/27/13 08:52 AM
its probably a prelude to trying to mandate everyone carry weapons in AZ..

but I cant see how it wouldnt be against the constitution (unless it isnt a law passed 'by congress', which is the actual limitation stated in the constitution)

and I Cant see how you can force people to not only pass their materials to graduate high school but to take a pledge to get the papers which purpose is to reflect that they passed the school work(not to reflect their level of patriotism or religion)


oldhippie1952's photo
Sun 01/27/13 08:54 AM
As a christian I am appalled.

Then again, a lot of it appalls me...ohwell

boredinaz06's photo
Sun 01/27/13 09:14 AM



I don't see a problem with this. I do have a problem with our employees trying to eradicate American pride, this will hopefully get some kids to think about what it means to be an American, what it means to have pride in your country and make em think that we're not immune to foreign hostilities.

no photo
Sun 01/27/13 09:40 AM
For anyone who didn't want to click on the link, here's the oath:

"I, _______, do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge these duties; So help me God."

There's absolutely no reason for this to be a requirement to graduate. It's completely over the top, but that doesn't surprise me coming from Arizona.

no photo
Sun 01/27/13 09:42 AM





The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile


Perhaps. But if any of those high school students went to court, would they be required to put their hand on a bible and swear to tell the truth "so help me God"?


The Constitution states that no Religious Test is required to hold Public Office!
Would be kind of absurd to demand a Religious test for Citizenship by those of whom no Religious Test is required!laugh


Graduation from High School isn't a public office or a test for citizenship. I suppose the goal is to introduce some patriotism into public schools but with today's climate, I am not sure the lawmakers aren't just shooting themselves in the foot with this one.:smile:


Forcing kids to say an oath like that isn't introducing patriotism. At least not real patriotism.

no photo
Sun 01/27/13 10:25 AM
"that I take this obligation freely"



laugh laugh laugh laugh laugh laugh laugh


Yeah. Making it mandatory to graduate is exactly how you get children to take an oath 'freely'.

metalwing's photo
Sun 01/27/13 11:11 AM






The oath seems "over the top a bit" but not really that far from the pledge of allegiance. It doesn't really seem to serve a useful purpose.
and probably be unconstitutional too!bigsmile


Perhaps. But if any of those high school students went to court, would they be required to put their hand on a bible and swear to tell the truth "so help me God"?


The Constitution states that no Religious Test is required to hold Public Office!
Would be kind of absurd to demand a Religious test for Citizenship by those of whom no Religious Test is required!laugh


Graduation from High School isn't a public office or a test for citizenship. I suppose the goal is to introduce some patriotism into public schools but with today's climate, I am not sure the lawmakers aren't just shooting themselves in the foot with this one.:smile:


Forcing kids to say an oath like that isn't introducing patriotism. At least not real patriotism.


I had to say the pledge of allegiance every day. Many others did too.

no photo
Sun 01/27/13 11:35 AM
Edited by singmesweet on Sun 01/27/13 11:36 AM


I had to say the pledge of allegiance every day. Many others did too.


Again, forcing kids to say an oath isn't real patriotism.

Can someone tell me what an oath like that mentioned in the OP has to do with education and why it should be said in order to graduate?

oldhippie1952's photo
Sun 01/27/13 11:42 AM



I had to say the pledge of allegiance every day. Many others did too.


Again, forcing kids to say an oath isn't real patriotism.

Can someone tell me what an oath like that mentioned in the OP has to do with education and why it should be said in order to graduate?


That's why it appalls me, kids have a hard enough time graduating.

I would like to see the pledge of allegiance restated though. When I was young it made me feel part of a whole.

TexasScoundrel's photo
Sun 01/27/13 01:42 PM
It's not an issue of patriotism. It's an issue of religion being forced down the throats of people that don't believe. A high school diploma is a minimum of what's needed to make a living. To deny it simply because of a disagreement of faith is ridicules.

Previous 1