1 2 3 4 6 8 9 10 44 45
Topic: Can an honest person not know what a lie is?
MonkeyBite's photo
Sat 03/24/12 07:35 PM




Welcome to the forums MonkeyBite. Are you basing this on bushido's claims?



that i was and ty


Thank you for joining in.




no problem happy
just checkin things out

creativesoul's photo
Sat 03/24/12 07:37 PM
Knowing how to lie requires first knowing how to not.

creativesoul's photo
Sat 03/24/12 07:39 PM





Welcome to the forums MonkeyBite. Are you basing this on bushido's claims?



that i was and ty


Thank you for joining in.




no problem happy
just checkin things out


Hopefully you'll stick around. I'm always happy to see good thinkers in the philosophy forum.

creativesoul's photo
Sat 03/24/12 08:34 PM
If you tell a lie, knowing it is a lie, you are a liar.

If you repeat a lie, thinking and believing that it is true, you could probably pass a lie detector test.

A liar creates a lie knowingly. But people spread lies unknowingly.

A spreader of lies is worse than a liar because people are more likely to believe them because they sound sincere.


I mostly agree with this, aside from a couple of minor things which do not seem to take away from the overall feel, but rather clarify it a little.

Liars are people too, and they can also sound sincere.

:wink:

AdventureBegins's photo
Sat 03/24/12 09:07 PM


But knowing the difference is the only way you can understand a 'lie'...

If you have not felt the depths you can not know the darkness and so aid one to life.

If you know only light you can not see the darkness (nor understand one who is in it).

If you know only the darkness the light is blinding and so you can not understand one who is in it (for you can not see them clearly)


but to be honest there is no "requirement" for u to have any knowledge of what a lie "is"; becuz u only speak "truth", thus "lying" would be alien to u

same goes for the opposite

on the same stone

if all u know is darkness, the "light" is alien, and would need explanations as to what it is; however, by your own example "only know the darkness" strengthens my own words, if you only know "this" than "that" must first be defined

eg you know darkness first off, first hand, the light is unknown becuz u've never done/experienced it

you stated u r but also know not ur opposite

to be one u do not need to know the other to be what u r

To be balanced within reality you must understand both...

Else you stumble about as one that is blind when you encounter 'otherness'.

no photo
Sat 03/24/12 09:33 PM
There is no such thing as an honest person...

Sin_and_Sorrow's photo
Sat 03/24/12 10:14 PM

There is no such thing as an honest person...


..yeah there is.

Down2earthdebbie's photo
Sat 03/24/12 10:29 PM


There is no such thing as an honest person...


..yeah there is.
yes I. Know there is....
Maybe hour used to dueshbags!!!!


Down2earthdebbie's photo
Sat 03/24/12 10:56 PM



There is no such thing as an honest person...


..yeah there is.
yes I. Know there is....
Maybe hour used to dueshbags!!!!


my is off with this touch screen. ..... douchebags for friends

doper's photo
Sat 03/24/12 11:52 PM
honesty is a human nature as abstinence is a sexual position. . . . . rofl pitchfork pitchfork

doper's photo
Sat 03/24/12 11:56 PM
cant there be an honest lier! ? Every body lies at a certain point to a certain extent. . Doest it make him dishonest if he lies 4 a gud cause?

Down2earthdebbie's photo
Sun 03/25/12 12:04 AM

cant there be an honest lier! ? Every body lies at a certain point to a certain extent. . Doest it make him dishonest if he lies 4 a gud cause?
uuummm there is No
good cause to LIE!!!!

doper's photo
Sun 03/25/12 12:31 AM
let me put it this way. Yr friends fiance cheatd on her only once . . . And he confesses in front o u that it was a big mirtake aftral . Poor fellow promises it wont happen again. He also begs u to lie to her. But u are such an honest person that u told her the truth. . Girl gets psychd . Kills herself. This makes the guy freak out and ends up in a mental asylum. . . Moral. . . Liers are humble honest people. . . :p. . .

Sin_and_Sorrow's photo
Sun 03/25/12 01:36 AM

honesty is a human nature as abstinence is a sexual position. . . . . rofl pitchfork pitchfork


So, you admit it?

"Masturbation" is, no matter how you sit/stand, is a sexual position.
So, thank you for agreeing. :P

Sin_and_Sorrow's photo
Sun 03/25/12 01:43 AM

let me put it this way. Yr friends fiance cheatd on her only once . . . And he confesses in front o u that it was a big mirtake aftral . Poor fellow promises it wont happen again. He also begs u to lie to her. But u are such an honest person that u told her the truth. . Girl gets psychd . Kills herself. This makes the guy freak out and ends up in a mental asylum. . . Moral. . . Liers are humble honest people. . . :p. . .


Your story makes absolutely no sense to your "point".

Moral:

"Liars are humble, honest people."

However, your story contradicts the moral.

The liar, lied, and to boot tried to have others back his lie.

The "honest" person, Debbie in this story, is told to lie, but then decides not to and reveals the ploy.

The honest person was honest.
..and all this after "honesty is nature--" etc, etc.
Yet proved its validity.
Awesome job.

I don't even have to debate it with you.
:smile:

doper's photo
Sun 03/25/12 02:01 AM
lol. Probably i gave a bad example. I admit my defeat. . Honesty is about being truthful. . . But trust me at times its not the best policy as THEY say. . .

Sin_and_Sorrow's photo
Sun 03/25/12 02:05 AM
Edited by Sin_and_Sorrow on Sun 03/25/12 02:06 AM

lol. Probably i gave a bad example. I admit my defeat. . Honesty is about being truthful. . . But trust me at times its not the best policy as THEY say. . .


Agreed.
lol

Despite what perfect Debbie believes. :P


no photo
Sun 03/25/12 05:00 AM
Knowing the difference between truth and lies is a different dispostion from being an honest person. Therefore, honesty is not a prerequisite to knowing the difference between truth and lies. You can only know if someone is liyinh if you know the truth, and if possible can prove it.

Down2earthdebbie's photo
Sun 03/25/12 08:31 AM


lol. Probably i gave a bad example. I admit my defeat. . Honesty is about being truthful. . . But trust me at times its not the best policy as THEY say. . .


Agreed.
lol

Despite what perfect Debbie believes. :P


uuummmm that's Not fair......... I never said, I was perfect........I just believe in the Truth no matter what!

no photo
Sun 03/25/12 10:09 AM
People lie because they think other people can't handle the truth.

Do you want to know the truth no matter how horrible it is? Can you handle the truth?


1 2 3 4 6 8 9 10 44 45