Topic: Our Baser Nature...good or evil?
1Cynderella's photo
Wed 05/15/13 01:25 PM


Do you believe we are basically good and some of us fall to poor behaviors, or that we are inherently bad and some conquer their baser nature to rise to goodness?

What are your thoughts?


i dont think we are born good or evil

I think we are born selfish and primal and have to be taught about right, wrong, conscious, and consderation for others,,,,
Okay, I'm down with this thinking.

We're born helpless and completely dependent..so, needy and selfish by natural design...which in this form is not a bad or evil thing.

I think a lot of people equate selfish with bad lr evil...though that's not the case at all.

MS...thanks for your two cents. You always have something thought provoking to add. flowerforyou

Saltoftheearth40's photo
Wed 05/15/13 01:27 PM

we're neither good nor evil we're born we're taught the difference between right and wrong and we then make our own decisions on how we're going to behave



this it's our free will.

1Cynderella's photo
Wed 05/15/13 02:06 PM



Having worked in forensic counseling for years, I have to side with the famous Park Dietz, who when asked this question simply smiled. I also don't wish to offend anybody or argue.
biggrin So...you're not volunteering to referee this one? what :laughing:


I will mention that one of the most popular books on forensic counseling is entitled "Bad Men Do What Good Men Dream"


While I'm not 100% sure I really want to know what bad men want, it will probably bump the next book on my list by virtue of your recommendation alone.

Thanks TB! biggrin


1Cynderella's photo
Wed 05/15/13 02:18 PM

You left "horny " out of the equation...

A horny person has no conscience.

For me..."good " or "evil "...goes with the situation.

Some days I am as good as baby Jesus smooching Mother Theresa.

Other days...I am Satan with a barbed wire hard on.

I just play to the situation....they change constantly.
Do you truly believe a horny person has no conscience?

So when I've said, "No thanks", I was just not 100% horny? frustrated

1Cynderella's photo
Wed 05/15/13 02:25 PM
Edited by 1Cynderella on Wed 05/15/13 02:27 PM



@SDSCF
I don't respond well to the silent treatment. explode :laughing:

no photo
Wed 05/15/13 02:40 PM
I like to think we are all born with goodness in our hearts
Some turn to evil as life throws all those damn curves at them
Some just choose to be evil for self gain
Evil is the easy path to walk in life
Choosing goodness is the path less traveled in these times i think
But striving to show and be that goodness
Makes the world a better place...

THE WORLD ROCKS
...Because of good folks like YOU !
happy happy\\
....\/....

Hi Cyndi !
...You're cute !
{hehehe}

flowerforyou
KiK

1Cynderella's photo
Wed 05/15/13 02:48 PM

I like to think we are all born with goodness in our hearts
Some turn to evil as life throws all those damn curves at them
Some just choose to be evil for self gain
Evil is the easy path to walk in life
Choosing goodness is the path less traveled in these times i think
But striving to show and be that goodness
Makes the world a better place...

THE WORLD ROCKS
...Because of good folks like YOU !
happy happy\\
....\/....

Hi Cyndi !
...You're cute !
{hehehe}

flowerforyou
KiK
flowerforyou You say the darndest things. laugh


no photo
Wed 05/15/13 04:05 PM
Edited by KiK2me on Wed 05/15/13 04:09 PM


I like to think we are all born with goodness in our hearts
Some turn to evil as life throws all those damn curves at them
Some just choose to be evil for self gain
Evil is the easy path to walk in life
Choosing goodness is the path less traveled in these times i think
But striving to show and be that goodness
Makes the world a better place...

THE WORLD ROCKS
...Because of good folks like YOU !
happy happy\\
....\/....

Hi Cyndi !
...You're cute !
{hehehe}

flowerforyou
KiK
flowerforyou You say the darndest things. laugh




tongue2
{slip us a little tongue ?}
rofl

oldsage's photo
Wed 05/15/13 06:02 PM
Capable of either, depends on my mood. Preferr good, but at times bad is necc.

metalwing's photo
Wed 05/15/13 06:58 PM
People are like dogs. Some are Labs and some are pit bulls.

BettyB's photo
Wed 05/15/13 07:03 PM

People are like dogs. Some are Labs and some are pit bulls.

laugh laugh laugh :thumbsup:

no photo
Thu 05/16/13 12:15 AM
I'm not quite sure how it all started but I don't think my K through 2nd grade teachers were too thrilled that I was breathing.

But, I do remember the day I had to go really bad and it took forever to get down the hall to the bathroom. I was so excited to finally be in front of my stall I broke the zipper tab off my pants and pee-d myself.

FearandLoathing's photo
Thu 05/16/13 12:47 AM

Do you believe we are basically good and some of us fall to poor behaviors, or that we are inherently bad and some conquer their baser nature to rise to goodness?

What are your thoughts?


Our nature is to survive, procreate, and conquer. If you are never taught how to survive then you rely on what you learn, which isn't necessarily right.

We are just clay hoping to be molded by the right people. Once in awhile the clay has a stain in it, and it cannot always be cleaned. We do the best we can with what we have.

1Cynderella's photo
Thu 05/16/13 07:54 AM


Do you believe we are basically good and some of us fall to poor behaviors, or that we are inherently bad and some conquer their baser nature to rise to goodness?

What are your thoughts?


Our nature is to survive, procreate, and conquer. If you are never taught how to survive then you rely on what you learn, which isn't necessarily right.

We are just clay hoping to be molded by the right people. Once in awhile the clay has a stain in it, and it cannot always be cleaned. We do the best we can with what we have.
I'm sure there is much truth in this.
Nice input Fear. flowerforyou

GLrider's photo
Thu 05/16/13 06:56 PM

Do you believe we are basically good and some of us fall to poor behaviors, or that we are inherently bad and some conquer their baser nature to rise to goodness?

What are your thoughts?


Generally people are good. It's when someone takes advantage of our good nature, is where the bad comes in. Then, it's more a control issue. Some will let it go. Others will seek retaliation for the bad they recieved. Depends on the person, and how much they will put up with.

no photo
Thu 05/16/13 07:54 PM


Do you believe we are basically good and some of us fall to poor behaviors, or that we are inherently bad and some conquer their baser nature to rise to goodness?

What are your thoughts?


Our nature is to survive, procreate, and conquer. If you are never taught how to survive then you rely on what you learn, which isn't necessarily right.

We are just clay hoping to be molded by the right people. Once in awhile the clay has a stain in it, and it cannot always be cleaned. We do the best we can with what we have.


do you think it's ever possible to do better than that?

FearandLoathing's photo
Thu 05/16/13 08:10 PM



Do you believe we are basically good and some of us fall to poor behaviors, or that we are inherently bad and some conquer their baser nature to rise to goodness?

What are your thoughts?


Our nature is to survive, procreate, and conquer. If you are never taught how to survive then you rely on what you learn, which isn't necessarily right.

We are just clay hoping to be molded by the right people. Once in awhile the clay has a stain in it, and it cannot always be cleaned. We do the best we can with what we have.


do you think it's ever possible to do better than that?


Better than what?

It is impossible to account for all of the variables present that can cause someone to do something horrific, just as it is impossible to account for all of the variables necessary for a person to grow up a productive member of society.

And then there are some people who just want to watch the world burn for the sake of watching it...The Ted Bundy's, Dahmer's, and Dennis Raders' of the world.

Better is subjective, but raw percentages we aren't doing too bad.

no photo
Thu 05/16/13 08:18 PM




Do you believe we are basically good and some of us fall to poor behaviors, or that we are inherently bad and some conquer their baser nature to rise to goodness?

What are your thoughts?


Our nature is to survive, procreate, and conquer. If you are never taught how to survive then you rely on what you learn, which isn't necessarily right.

We are just clay hoping to be molded by the right people. Once in awhile the clay has a stain in it, and it cannot always be cleaned. We do the best we can with what we have.


do you think it's ever possible to do better than that?


Better than what?

It is impossible to account for all of the variables present that can cause someone to do something horrific, just as it is impossible to account for all of the variables necessary for a person to grow up a productive member of society.

And then there are some people who just want to watch the world burn for the sake of watching it...The Ted Bundy's, Dahmer's, and Dennis Raders' of the world.

Better is subjective, but raw percentages we aren't doing too bad.


better is particularly subjective when "what" is not well defined or defined at all. but I was responding to your idea that we do the best we can with what we have. Can we exceed that? or is it closer to an absolute?

honestly I am equally fascinated by those who come from the worst possible environmental conditions and achieve & succeed or find some kind of peace love & happiness

your comment reminded me of those people - the ones who miraculously rise above

fascinated by those exceptions

FearandLoathing's photo
Thu 05/16/13 09:31 PM
I don't think we can do better, but I also don't think we are doing all that terrible currently.

It would require too many variables working correctly to make much use of the end result. I honestly think that the day we fully understand how the brain works is the day we quit progressing, so I hope it never occurs.

no photo
Fri 05/17/13 08:24 PM

I don't think we can do better, but I also don't think we are doing all that terrible currently.

It would require too many variables working correctly to make much use of the end result. I honestly think that the day we fully understand how the brain works is the day we quit progressing, so I hope it never occurs.


I think of it as infinity...the day we understand how the brain works we will also understand how much more there is to learn and so it goes.......


I think we can - do better - I think one thing that makes us uniquely human is that we can take our actual (versus perceived) potential and re-form it, change it, build on it, or in the worst case, destroy it. We can do the best we can with what we have ... and build on that. it's potential, becoming realized and a new potential forms

free will & potential, intelligence and motivation, a time to understand and a time to grow. I hope we never stop growing