Topic: Does Space have Sound?
adj4u's photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:29 AM

Greetings Adj4u

I come in pieces



well pull yourself together
drinker laugh

Joseph420420's photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:29 AM
just liek if they are in theyre suits on the outside working of the craft theyre not goign to be floatign there without a suit on workign on the outside of theyre craft or theyd DIE

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:29 AM
Let us find out! I have a few space suits available. Maybe we can borrow the space shuttle one daylaugh drinker

tngxl65's photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:41 AM
'Sound' as we generally think of it, which is vibrations which are then interpreted by your ears, cannot travel through space as there is no medium. There has to be a conduit of some sort.... air, water, concrete, space suit, whatever. However electromagnetic 'sound' which isn't really sound at all, travels through space just fine. However to hear it, it has to be 'translated' to something we can hear. It's what your radio and tv does. The radio station takes sound waves, converts them to either an analog or digital representation of them, and sends to your radio, which converts them back to sounds. When you hear static on your radio it's simply background electromagnetic interference being 'interpreted' as sound, not 'sound' as we generally think of it.

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:43 AM


...if you fart in space is it ..stinky...:laughing: ..and if not than that just sucks...:laughing: ..i for one would feel cheated and therefore space would piss me off...:laughing:

Joseph420420's photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:44 AM



...if you fart in space is it ..stinky...:laughing: ..and if not than that just sucks...:laughing: ..i for one would feel cheated and therefore space would piss me off...:laughing:
if you wnt into space without a suit all the air in your body would e scked out ...

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:45 AM

'Sound' as we generally think of it, which is vibrations which are then interpreted by your ears, cannot travel through space as there is no medium. There has to be a conduit of some sort.... air, water, concrete, space suit, whatever. However electromagnetic 'sound' which isn't really sound at all, travels through space just fine. However to hear it, it has to be 'translated' to something we can hear. It's what your radio and tv does. The radio station takes sound waves, converts them to either an analog or digital representation of them, and sends to your radio, which converts them back to sounds. When you hear static on your radio it's simply background electromagnetic interference being 'interpreted' as sound, not 'sound' as we generally think of it.


and there you go. This is a logical explanation indeed. drinker

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 07:50 AM
laugh drinker I guess with that being said the thread dies

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 08:19 AM

I ask this because it was said that in space there is no sound.

So this means if you where to watch a realistic Star Wars movie there would be no sound when galactic ships fight against the rebels by shooting their photons or the engines wouldn't be heard when flying by?

What is the reality behind this?

Is there sound or no sound.

Is gravity a factor or not?

What makes sound?

Is it just frequencies and waves?

ONLY IF YOU FART IN SPACE..........

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 08:26 AM
Alot of people must be having gases to mention it on the threads! Stop eating those burritoslaugh drinker

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 09:25 AM


so one says no and the other says yeslaugh drinker

you need atmoshere to resonate



Agree!drinks

no photo
Tue 08/25/09 10:20 AM
Sound waves require a material medium to travel. Space usually does not offer such a medium.

If two astronauts out in the void of space put there helmets together and yelled they could probably hear each other by the contact of the helmets and the air in there suits: yes.


Kealst's photo
Tue 08/25/09 10:39 AM
In the vacuum there is no sound, however sound can travel through space. Sound = vibrations. No molecules to vibrate = no sound.


HulloThar's photo
Tue 08/25/09 03:42 PM
Sound is vibration, in a perfect vacuum there is nothing to vibrate, if there's something to hear the vibration it's not a vacuum.

Space has matter which can vibrate and will produce sound, so yes there is sound in space when you're close to a ship, meteor and/or whatever else.

SkyHook5652's photo
Tue 08/25/09 05:34 PM
Edited by SkyHook5652 on Tue 08/25/09 05:35 PM
By definition, sound is vibration.

So if there is nothing to vibrate (a vacuum) there can be no sound.

edit: Sorry Hullo, I see you already made that point. drinker

earthytaurus76's photo
Tue 08/25/09 06:04 PM
yeah.. it sounds like this


WA-- ZOOOMMMMMMMMMMMM!


HulloThar's photo
Tue 08/25/09 10:34 PM

By definition, sound is vibration.

So if there is nothing to vibrate (a vacuum) there can be no sound.

edit: Sorry Hullo, I see you already made that point. drinker

quite alright

Joseph420420's photo
Tue 08/25/09 10:48 PM
this thread is redundant.

tngxl65's photo
Tue 08/25/09 10:55 PM

this thread is redundant.


I prefer to think of it as 'highly available'

Joseph420420's photo
Tue 08/25/09 10:57 PM


this thread is redundant.


I prefer to think of it as 'highly available'
as highly available?, theres not much more that can be said bout sounds traveling through space every ones sayign the same thign over and over, lol but i suppose your right