1 2 3 5 7 8 9 13 14
Topic: Stand your ground Law should it be changed or reformed?
MadDog1974's photo
Tue 02/17/15 06:28 PM








That excuse has also been used for decades. Let's just throw more money at a failed system because some people are irresponsible. The easy answer, and somewhat harsh, is if you can't feed 'em, don't breed 'em. But families, churches and charities take care of people more effectively and more efficiently than the government.


that's ridiculous actually, because it ignores the fact that children grow over a period of 18 years,, during which all types of things can happen that constitute 'hard times'

whether you can afford them at one point doesn't GUARANTEE you will always be able to do it ,,,,,things change, that's reality

and children shouldn't be left to suffer when those hard times hit their parents..




Prior to the government "helping" people by encouraging them to remain on the dole churches, communities, charities, and families handled these issues more effectively and efficiently. Or did you intentionally overlook that part? More of the same policies will yield more of the same results. I'm not ok with sending the poor a message that they can't move up. Why are you?



prior to the overwhelming need for help, families stayed together and MEN provided

after the great depression, and the great wars, poverty rates became unable to be managed thru mere churches and charities

the population grew quite a bit, families breaking up became more acceptable,

the job industry changed , manufacturing took a great hit, technology and ecommerce grew,,


and the times changed along with them so that what USED to work no longer was enough,,,

it still isn't,, this isn't 1945


Im not ok with sending the poor the message that they should be grateful to be workhorse/slaves? Are you?

I agree things can improve, but I don't agree that welfare is the problem. people will fall on hard times and need help, not all of them go to churches or have access to a charity that isn't already overwhelmed,,,


the problem is about training and educating people about how to strive, and not just struggle and survive,,,

about adapting the system to the changing needs of the population,,,,

about encouraging the 'job makers' to pay decent wage for the time and efforts of honest people trying to survive,,,

about re vamping the 'credit' system that almost mandates people take on debt to prove themselves worthy of decent home rates, loan rates, insurance rates,,, and any number of other things that are now standards in our culture,,,

..lots of improvements can be made,, ditching the help so many depend upon through the rough times is not one of them



Again, "you can't, so you need me." That's almost like an abusive marriage, is it not? Why do you support policies that have failed for decades?


according to whom have they failed?

if the economy wasn't 'failing' families which need decent wages and opportunities, welfare could work even better


assistance programs keep millions off the streets and with food in their bellies, a good portion of them children and elderly

why cant you understand that its human to 'need' to need some help sometime,, there is no shame in it and it has nothing to do with 'can't' ?





According to the fact that we have a growing number of people ON the system instead of getting OFF the system! But more money will make a bad idea good, I suppose. whoa whoa whoa whoa



a better economy will make a good idea better

when there is a depression or recession, SURPRISE< more people will need more help

however , most on welfare(the types people complain about , mainly aid to family and stamps for food), are not on longer than 3-5 years,,, so it is TEMPORARY for when people have hard times,, and that's not a dent on character when it happens

most don't enjoy trying to feed 4 people on 300 a month or pay their expenses for a family of 4 with another 300 on a card

its a temporary means until they get back on their feet

everyone needs some help sometimes,,,




Didn't you say Obama is fixing the economy? So why MORE welfare cases? And 3 -5 YEARS? That's a long time, and the longer someone is DEPENDENT, the harder it is to become independent. So let's keep throwing more money into a failed system because more money will fix it. Just like a little more gasoline should put out that fire. Again, why do you favor dependence on government instead of freedom?

msharmony's photo
Tue 02/17/15 06:32 PM
you keep ignoring the information I am giving..

the economy needs to work better
welfare is not the problem and needs to be available for when people hit rough patches

doesnt matter how hard it is to become independent, there is a TIME SET since Clintons reform that only allows the time it allows


the welfare doesn't fail, the economy does



freedom is a nice clich� soundbyte to make things sound good

but it doesn't work for starvation and homelessness, at least not with me

Id prefer my kids have shelter and food,,,

MadDog1974's photo
Tue 02/17/15 06:44 PM
You keep repeating yourself, which is why I keep ignoring you. Gee, kinda like we keep throwing money at welfare and we keep getting more people on the dole! Wow! Same actions yield same results! See how it works now?whoa whoa frustrated frustrated frustrated frustrated

Dodo_David's photo
Tue 02/17/15 07:10 PM
Wow, this thread has really gone off topic.

msharmony's photo
Tue 02/17/15 10:59 PM
Edited by msharmony on Tue 02/17/15 10:59 PM

You keep repeating yourself, which is why I keep ignoring you. Gee, kinda like we keep throwing money at welfare and we keep getting more people on the dole! Wow! Same actions yield same results! See how it works now?whoa whoa frustrated frustrated frustrated frustrated


no,, I see the rEALITY and the actual numbers, and not assumptions

there is a record number since we hit the last RECESSION, that is not the normal trend,,,,

the numbers have hit highs and lows before the recession, it goes in waves when the numbers decline and increase,,,,thats the NORM

it works, but it could work BETTER if we didn't have an economy that produced so many working poor,,, if the work actually combated the poverty, fewer people would require the dole to get on their feet






try as you may to keep indicting the impoverished instead of poverty itself,,,,but welfare is still a necessary blanket for americans on hard times,,

msharmony's photo
Tue 02/17/15 11:01 PM

Wow, this thread has really gone off topic.


I agree. I did point that out a couple posts ago. But you know poverty is an issue that I have to speak up about when I hear people begrudging the impoverished.

no photo
Wed 02/18/15 12:08 AM
Edited by Estelle79 on Wed 02/18/15 12:09 AM
When I see people talk about the poor feeling entitled to welfare, I totally agree that they should feel entitled. And who wouldn't need to resort to theft or other crime when welfare means you can't afford shelter. Where in the world does rent cost under $300?

ALBYAK's photo
Wed 02/18/15 08:01 AM

When I see people talk about the poor feeling entitled to welfare, I totally agree that they should feel entitled. And who wouldn't need to resort to theft or other crime when welfare means you can't afford shelter. Where in the world does rent cost under $300?


Can someone tell me why we are letting this lady from "Istanbul, Istanbul"oops lead us into questioning our "Stand your ground" laws or question our welfare system in the US WTF are we doing hereslaphead

Maybe we should start checking out the OP's before letting them divide US.whoa

She is siting back rofl at us for being so stupid!spock

no photo
Wed 02/18/15 08:25 AM


When I see people talk about the poor feeling entitled to welfare, I totally agree that they should feel entitled. And who wouldn't need to resort to theft or other crime when welfare means you can't afford shelter. Where in the world does rent cost under $300?


Can someone tell me why we are letting this lady from "Istanbul, Istanbul"oops lead us into questioning our "Stand your ground" laws or question our welfare system in the US WTF are we doing hereslaphead

Maybe we should start checking out the OP's before letting them divide US.whoa

She is siting back rofl at us for being so stupid!spock


This website does not allow me to write Istanbul, Turkey so that is not my mistake.
I'm American and the profile asks where do you live? I live in another country and this is an international forum. I'm not dividing anyone, this is a place to discuss all kinds of political views.
I'm not laughing because it's not very funny. It's sad that people can be so cruel to those suffering from poverty.

ALBYAK's photo
Wed 02/18/15 09:13 AM
My apology, but seems many who are not American start garbage on here to stir us up. Looked at your profile before I wrote that and saw nothing to indicate you are a proud American........located somewhere else.

Conrad_73's photo
Wed 02/18/15 10:08 AM
Edited by Conrad_73 on Wed 02/18/15 10:08 AM

and the kids?

yes, adults who don't have to don't have to do ANYTHING BUT look after themselves, I understand

but the children who suffer along with the adults when they hit hard times, make that a bit less doable without some help


"As long as the government is perceived as working for the benefit of the children, the people will happily endure almost any curtailment of liberty and almost any deprivation. ~ Adolf Hitler

Conrad_73's photo
Wed 02/18/15 10:25 AM
yep,great Selfdefense-Strategy!
Just turn the Other Cheek!

#one!

#two!

#three!

#four,oops,now what!laugh

msharmony's photo
Wed 02/18/15 10:50 AM


and the kids?

yes, adults who don't have to don't have to do ANYTHING BUT look after themselves, I understand

but the children who suffer along with the adults when they hit hard times, make that a bit less doable without some help


"As long as the government is perceived as working for the benefit of the children, the people will happily endure almost any curtailment of liberty and almost any deprivation. ~ Adolf Hitler


Ill pass on taking advice from hitler, thanks,,

no photo
Wed 02/18/15 11:15 AM
Erdogan...nevermind don't want to get in trouble.

MadDog1974's photo
Wed 02/18/15 11:35 AM


Wow, this thread has really gone off topic.


I agree. I did point that out a couple posts ago. But you know poverty is an issue that I have to speak up about when I hear people begrudging the impoverished.


The mistake you make is your assumption that I think the impoverished are the problem. The problem is the politicians who promote policies that keep people impoverished. It is no coincidence that the impoverished areas also have the worst schools. But then again, offering educational options other than the failing public schools in those areas is also a bad idea according to the same people who promote the policies that make it difficult to pull themselves out of poverty. So now the question is, why do those who promote policies that perpetuate poverty also oppose educating the impoverished? Perhaps for the same reason that it was illegal for slaves to be educated 200 years ago?

no photo
Wed 02/18/15 01:29 PM
But you called them lazy and want to kick them to the street. There they will get a street education, is that what you mean by education?

no photo
Wed 02/18/15 01:31 PM



Wow, this thread has really gone off topic.


I agree. I did point that out a couple posts ago. But you know poverty is an issue that I have to speak up about when I hear people begrudging the impoverished.


The mistake you make is your assumption that I think the impoverished are the problem. The problem is the politicians who promote policies that keep people impoverished. It is no coincidence that the impoverished areas also have the worst schools. But then again, offering educational options other than the failing public schools in those areas is also a bad idea according to the same people who promote the policies that make it difficult to pull themselves out of poverty. So now the question is, why do those who promote policies that perpetuate poverty also oppose educating the impoverished? Perhaps for the same reason that it was illegal for slaves to be educated 200 years ago?


:thumbsup:

MadDog1974's photo
Wed 02/18/15 01:39 PM

But you called them lazy and want to kick them to the street. There they will get a street education, is that what you mean by education?


Obfuscating and putting words in people's mouths doesn't answer the question.

no photo
Wed 02/18/15 02:26 PM


But you called them lazy and want to kick them to the street. There they will get a street education, is that what you mean by education?


Obfuscating and putting words in people's mouths doesn't answer the question.


Exactly..so answer the question?


MadDog1974's photo
Wed 02/18/15 02:35 PM



But you called them lazy and want to kick them to the street. There they will get a street education, is that what you mean by education?


Obfuscating and putting words in people's mouths doesn't answer the question.


Exactly..so answer the question?




I asked a question that was avoided. Why is that? Why perpetuate policies that promote poverty, while at the same time opposing better educational opportunities for the impoverished? Why will no one answer that question?

1 2 3 5 7 8 9 13 14