Topic: Is Knowledge a Gift from Satan - part 2
s1owhand's photo
Tue 07/06/10 11:02 AM




"God is the Creator of Everything


wouldn't that also mean that God is the creator of Nothing?




ok - so what big deal. nothing is a subset of everything.
god also created boogers which is also a subset of everything.


no...nothing is not the subset of everything.....nothing is the opposite of everything

there are clearly things that God did not create....did God create himself?


ridiculous. everything contains nothing trivially.

god is, was and always will be. eternal. so the question of
whether god created god is meaningless. but if you want to
think of it that way then i suppose that is ok too.

laugh

no photo
Tue 07/06/10 12:28 PM

ridiculous. everything contains nothing trivially.

god is, was and always will be. eternal. so the question of
whether god created god is meaningless. but if you want to
think of it that way then i suppose that is ok too.

laugh


you said that God is the creator of everything ....if God didn't create himself then God is clearly not the creator of everything ...simple logic

according to religious logic everything must have a creator and couldn't have just pop out of nothingness....that also applies to God ... since God didn't create himself then something else had to create him....

God may be "always was"....but he was created by something that "always been"

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 01:20 PM


ridiculous. everything contains nothing trivially.

god is, was and always will be. eternal. so the question of
whether god created god is meaningless. but if you want to
think of it that way then i suppose that is ok too.

laugh


you said that God is the creator of everything ....if God didn't create himself then God is clearly not the creator of everything ...simple logic

according to religious logic everything must have a creator and couldn't have just pop out of nothingness....that also applies to God ... since God didn't create himself then something else had to create him....

God may be "always was"....but he was created by something that "always been"


God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.

Inkracer's photo
Tue 07/06/10 02:27 PM



ridiculous. everything contains nothing trivially.

god is, was and always will be. eternal. so the question of
whether god created god is meaningless. but if you want to
think of it that way then i suppose that is ok too.

laugh


you said that God is the creator of everything ....if God didn't create himself then God is clearly not the creator of everything ...simple logic

according to religious logic everything must have a creator and couldn't have just pop out of nothingness....that also applies to God ... since God didn't create himself then something else had to create him....

God may be "always was"....but he was created by something that "always been"


God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


That is special pleading. Whether you like it or not, whatever you say about the universe also applies to your god. If everything has to have a creator then so does your god, if your god has always been, then it is also possible for the universe to have always been.

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 03:48 PM
Edited by CowboyGH on Tue 07/06/10 03:49 PM




ridiculous. everything contains nothing trivially.

god is, was and always will be. eternal. so the question of
whether god created god is meaningless. but if you want to
think of it that way then i suppose that is ok too.

laugh


you said that God is the creator of everything ....if God didn't create himself then God is clearly not the creator of everything ...simple logic

according to religious logic everything must have a creator and couldn't have just pop out of nothingness....that also applies to God ... since God didn't create himself then something else had to create him....

God may be "always was"....but he was created by something that "always been"


God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


That is special pleading. Whether you like it or not, whatever you say about the universe also applies to your god. If everything has to have a creator then so does your god, if your god has always been, then it is also possible for the universe to have always been.


The universe probably has always been, but the life on this planet hasn't. God is the alpha and the omega, the begining and the end. There CAN'T be nothing before the begining.

no photo
Tue 07/06/10 04:29 PM

God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:17 PM


God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.

Inkracer's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:21 PM



God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


Tell yourself that all you want, it still fails the logic test.

no photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:23 PM



God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


there were a pre-alpha ...God's creator

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:23 PM




God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


Tell yourself that all you want, it still fails the logic test.


How does it fail a logic test? and what logic test? And who's logic?

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:24 PM




God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


there were a pre-alpha ...God's creator


That statement doesn't even make sence, something can NOT be before the first.

no photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:29 PM





God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


there were a pre-alpha ...God's creator


That statement doesn't even make sence, something can NOT be before the first.


again you are wrong...a proto-type or a demo can exist before the first ....God's ancestors

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:30 PM






God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


there were a pre-alpha ...God's creator


That statement doesn't even make sence, something can NOT be before the first.


again you are wrong...a proto-type or a demo can exist before the first ....God's ancestors


no, because then God's ancestors would have been the alpha/begining.

no photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:34 PM







God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


there were a pre-alpha ...God's creator


That statement doesn't even make sence, something can NOT be before the first.


again you are wrong...a proto-type or a demo can exist before the first ....God's ancestors


no, because then God's ancestors would have been the alpha/begining.


they were...

Inkracer's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:34 PM





God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


Tell yourself that all you want, it still fails the logic test.


How does it fail a logic test? and what logic test? And who's logic?


God has to be an extremely complex thing, (to use Dawkins' words) a god would be the ultimate 747.
Science has done a nice job of showing that simplicity gives raise to complexity. (Through evolution).
By using the logic we get from Science (or just re-working the creationist argument)
For God to be as complex as he is, there HAD to be something before god. Either for him to evolve from, or for him to be created from.

Personally, we have natural explanations for everything we understand, I don't see a need to invoke the supernatural for things we don't fully understand yet.

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:37 PM






God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


Tell yourself that all you want, it still fails the logic test.


How does it fail a logic test? and what logic test? And who's logic?


God has to be an extremely complex thing, (to use Dawkins' words) a god would be the ultimate 747.
Science has done a nice job of showing that simplicity gives raise to complexity. (Through evolution).
By using the logic we get from Science (or just re-working the creationist argument)
For God to be as complex as he is, there HAD to be something before god. Either for him to evolve from, or for him to be created from.

Personally, we have natural explanations for everything we understand, I don't see a need to invoke the supernatural for things we don't fully understand yet.


God didn't have to go through evolution and all that, none of the natural laws we have on earth apply to God, for God created those laws. If God wishes for it to be, it is. So that is kinda irrelevant about evolution.

Inkracer's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:38 PM



God has to be an extremely complex thing, (to use Dawkins' words) a god would be the ultimate 747.
Science has done a nice job of showing that simplicity gives raise to complexity. (Through evolution).
By using the logic we get from Science (or just re-working the creationist argument)
For God to be as complex as he is, there HAD to be something before god. Either for him to evolve from, or for him to be created from.

Personally, we have natural explanations for everything we understand, I don't see a need to invoke the supernatural for things we don't fully understand yet.


God didn't have to go through evolution and all that, none of the natural laws we have on earth apply to God, for God created those laws. If God wishes for it to be, it is. So that is kinda irrelevant about evolution.


IF god does anything in the natural world, then the natural laws apply to him too.

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:40 PM








God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


there were a pre-alpha ...God's creator


That statement doesn't even make sence, something can NOT be before the first.


again you are wrong...a proto-type or a demo can exist before the first ....God's ancestors


no, because then God's ancestors would have been the alpha/begining.


they were...


How could there have been funches? Just how? How can something be before the begining of everything? And i mean EVERYTHING, not just this planet, this galaxy, ANYTHING and EVERYTHING that ever did or does exist. It's not possible, God is/was before Everything.

CowboyGH's photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:42 PM




God has to be an extremely complex thing, (to use Dawkins' words) a god would be the ultimate 747.
Science has done a nice job of showing that simplicity gives raise to complexity. (Through evolution).
By using the logic we get from Science (or just re-working the creationist argument)
For God to be as complex as he is, there HAD to be something before god. Either for him to evolve from, or for him to be created from.

Personally, we have natural explanations for everything we understand, I don't see a need to invoke the supernatural for things we don't fully understand yet.


God didn't have to go through evolution and all that, none of the natural laws we have on earth apply to God, for God created those laws. If God wishes for it to be, it is. So that is kinda irrelevant about evolution.


IF god does anything in the natural world, then the natural laws apply to him too.


Not exactly cause everything that does happen in the world happens only because God allows it to happen. That is the only reason for evolution, because God allows it. Doesn't happen because it is what happened to him, it happens because he ALLOWS it to happen.

no photo
Tue 07/06/10 05:45 PM









God wasn't created, God has always been and will always be.


a pretty catchy phrase but it doesn't mean that God wasn't created

can anyone that believe in God deny that God had a first thought? .....that first thought was formed from that which existed before God existence ...


There was no before God's existance. God is the alpha and omega, the begining and the end.


there were a pre-alpha ...God's creator


That statement doesn't even make sence, something can NOT be before the first.


again you are wrong...a proto-type or a demo can exist before the first ....God's ancestors


no, because then God's ancestors would have been the alpha/begining.


they were...


How could there have been funches? Just how? How can something be before the begining of everything? And i mean EVERYTHING, not just this planet, this galaxy, ANYTHING and EVERYTHING that ever did or does exist. It's not possible, God is/was before Everything.


Cowboy...aren't you trying to claim that God exist before everything ...I have no dispute with that....I'm just saying that something also existed before God